We're finding there's a detrimental layer when you hit four emails a week.
Brian CampbellFounder, CrucialPointForty-three percent of shoppers who unsubscribe from a brand's emails or texts say they liked the brand but received too many messages, according to Attentive's 2026 State of Loyalty & Retention survey of 600 US consumers. (The CMO Wire is powered by Attentive.) Yet 65% of shoppers say they're open to hearing from brands more often when the messages are relevant, according to the company's Personalization Trends research. Lifecycle leaders interviewed by CMO Wire say the right frequency depends on the subscriber, and that holiday sending makes the difference more expensive.
Why do subscribers really unsubscribe?
Volume is the top reason, but relevance runs close behind. In Attentive's loyalty survey, 43% of unsubscribers said they got too many messages overall. Another 36% said the messages were irrelevant, 30% said the brand sent too many messages about the same thing, and 28% kept getting purchase reminders after they had already bought.
The problem starts early. In separate Attentive research on list growth, half of email subscribers and half of SMS subscribers said they had recently unsubscribed soon after signing up, most often because of message volume.
Relevance and volume are linked. In Attentive's 2026 Personalization Trends survey, eighty percent of shoppers said they're more likely to ignore brands that send irrelevant messages, and 56% say they often or very often receive them. A subscriber who gets four useful messages a week may feel fine, while one who gets two irrelevant ones may leave.
Is there a right number of messages per week?
Not one that fits every subscriber. Attentive's cross-channel coordination research found preferences spread across the range. About a third of shoppers said they'd accept daily messages on a given channel, roughly a quarter to a third preferred a few times a week, and the rest wanted weekly or less. Seventy-five percent said brands should adjust frequency based on how they engage.
Brian Campbell, founder and CEO of CrucialPoint, spent years at Overstock.com, where sending more emails was part of the strategy. His experience working with quick-service restaurant clients, however, showed him the downside of that approach. "We're finding there's a detrimental layer when you hit four emails a week," he told CMO Wire. "You start causing reverse loyalty metrics. Users start dropping out of the funnel, they start deleting the app."
Campbell doesn't argue against daily sending. He recommends capping how many messages each person receives in a week, for example three, and testing that cap by cohort.
How do brands match frequency to engagement?
By segmenting on how each subscriber responds. Attentive's guide to email marketing segmentation recommends layering recency, value and engagement, and treating inactive audiences differently to protect deliverability. A subscriber who clicks every text but rarely opens email can get more texts and fewer emails. One who has gone quiet can move to a lower-frequency track or a re-engagement series.
Kuki Vincent-Osei, CEO of Republik Marketing, told CMO Wire that full-list sends should be the exception. "If you have a new launch, it's okay here and there to send it out to your entire list, but everything should be highly segmented," she said.
Reporting has to follow the same logic. Campbell said channel-level dashboards can make heavy sending look like it's working. "If you look at the wrong metrics, it will show you that what you're doing is correct, when in fact it may not be," he said. Unsubscribe and complaint rates by segment show where the cap is too high.
Does sending the same offer on email and SMS cause fatigue?
Usually not, if each message adds something. Sixty percent of shoppers in Attentive's loyalty survey said they're fine seeing the same promotion on more than one channel, and 28% found it helpful. Thirty percent said they felt overwhelmed, and that group was more likely to unsubscribe over repetition and post-purchase reminders. Follow-ups that add reviews, product details or a deadline, rather than repeating the first message, keep multichannel campaigns on the right side of that line.
What should holiday cadence look like?
Higher overall volume, with the same per-subscriber limits. Brands can raise the number of campaigns in November while still controlling how many each person receives. The most engaged subscribers can take more, while lapsed subscribers should hear less and be re-engaged before peak week rather than during it.
Purchase suppression matters most in this period. Twenty-eight percent of unsubscribers cited reminders after they had already bought, and holiday shoppers often buy on one device after browsing on another. Brands that can't connect those sessions will send more of those reminders at exactly the wrong time.
CMO Wire's guides to email deliverability before Black Friday and coordinating email, SMS and push cover the related steps.
FAQ
How many marketing emails per week is too many? It varies by subscriber. Brian Campbell of CrucialPoint says his team sees negative effects at around four emails a week for many brands, and recommends capping how many messages each person receives while testing the cap by cohort.
Why do customers unsubscribe from marketing emails and texts? The most common reasons in Attentive's 2026 loyalty survey were too many messages overall (43%), irrelevant messages (36%), repeated messages about the same offer (30%) and purchase reminders after buying (28%).
Will customers accept more messages if they're relevant? Many will. Sixty-five percent of shoppers say they're open to more frequent messages when those messages are relevant, according to Attentive's Personalization Trends research.
Is it OK to send the same promotion by email and SMS? Yes, for most shoppers. Sixty percent say they're fine seeing the same promotion on more than one channel. Follow-up messages should add something new, such as reviews, product details or a deadline, rather than repeat the first one.
Should brands send more messages during Black Friday and Cyber Monday? Most brands raise total campaign volume in November, but per-subscriber limits should still apply. Engaged subscribers can receive more, while lapsed subscribers should be re-engaged earlier in the month rather than mailed heavily during peak week.




