Understanding the relationship between search visibility, competitive dynamics and business performance helps us make more informed investment decisions. It allows us to prioritize resources where they can deliver the greatest commercial impact and contribute to sustainable, profitable growth.

Kara FarnhamKara FarnhamDirector, Commerce Media & Enablement @ The Hershey Company

The views and opinions expressed are those of the individuals and do not represent the official policy or position of any organization.

Retail media is on course to take almost a quarter of all US media spend by 2028, and each network still reports performance on its own terms. Some advertisers have started questioning those increases, with agencies warning of diminishing returns as the number of networks grows. A brand-side leader weighing that spend needs efficiency measures as a guardrail and a clear view of what the investment is meant to do for the business.

Kara Farnham is Director of Commerce Media and Enablement at The Hershey Company, where she leads retail media, analytics, and digital content for the snack and candy maker's omnichannel sales organization. She took the role in October 2025, after leading media strategic investments, partnerships, and omnichannel operations at Hershey. Farnham has spent close to 20 years in commerce and shopper marketing, including six years at Mondelēz International.

"Understanding the relationship between search visibility, competitive dynamics and business performance helps us make more informed investment decisions. It allows us to prioritize resources where they can deliver the greatest commercial impact and contribute to sustainable, profitable growth," says Farnham. Visibility and sales can be lined up against each other on search, the side of retail media where a visibility measure already exists. The evidence shows what a business stands to gain and what it stands to give up, and for Farnham both belong in how the investment gets evaluated.

Visibility and sales together

A brand's share of voice on a retailer's search results can be counted week-to-week and lined up against what the brand sold in the same period. Comparing those measures can help a brand assess the business implications of changing visibility. "What risk are we assuming if we allow share of voice to decline, and what could that ultimately mean for sales?" asks Farnham.

The same link shows up on the physical shelf, where a brand can watch presence and sales move together. Athena Kasvikis, Founder and CEO of Behave Bras, points back to the Gillette rebrand during her years in brand management at Procter & Gamble, when a cleaner design changed how shoppers found the brand in the aisle. "It looked the same, but it changed how people shopped that aisle in the store," she says. "They didn't get the brand block of color anymore." The redesign cost real volume almost overnight, she recalls, a reminder that losing visibility, whether on a shelf or on a results page, shows up in sales before much else does.

Display carries a different job, connecting what a shopper sees across the full funnel, and the objective behind a display buy changes from campaign to campaign. Some of those objectives carry a number, and others are about presence, partnership, or brand investment that pays back over a longer horizon.

Ryan Willette, Global Head of Customer Success, Partnerships, and Account Management at Attentive, a leading SMS and email marketing platform, sees that split constantly. "Every brand I work with has some spend they can tie straight to revenue and some they're making because the relationship matters. Both are legitimate. The problem starts when nobody writes down which is which, then everything gets judged on the same number, and the relationship spend looks like a loss," says Willette.

Measures beside the ROI

Marketing mix modeling is where display spend usually gets read, and the AI-based models now returning monthly reads make that faster than it used to be. For Farnham the ROI figure works as a guardrail worth keeping, and the open question is which other indicators belong beside it. Willette hears that same question in his work. "The brands getting the clearest read pair the efficiency number with something that shows whether customers are coming back. Repeat purchase, retention, how many new customers they're actually reaching. One number tells you whether the spend was efficient, and the others tell you whether it built anything," he adds.

Reading each channel on its own number is where that goes wrong, says Elina Vilk, President and Chief Business Officer of David's Bridal. She likens it to a doctor with only 30 minutes who treats the symptom in front of them and misses the cause running through the whole body. "That's what happens when an email team says clicks are down and wants more budget for email, or the website team says conversion is down and wants more retargeting spend," she says. "Nobody's saying we need a top-of-funnel brand awareness campaign that would float all boats." A single channel's efficiency read can look healthy while the investment that would lift all of them goes unmade.

Share growth is one of the outcomes Farnham would put in that set, alongside the efficiency read, and she treats it as one input in a wider set. She's also candid that the question isn't settled, and peers at other CPG companies describe the same gap. It's part of the reason the industry keeps pushing retail media networks toward consistent methodology. "We know it's important and we know it's driving impact, but we don't yet have the consistency in measurement we need to build every business case with confidence. And I don't think we're alone in that."

Judging the performance story

Every retailer reports its own performance numbers, and Farnham reads them as one input among several. She points to a simple arithmetic check as the reason. "When we look across retailers collectively, there can be more sales attributed to media than the business actually delivered. That's why retailer-reported performance has to be one input within a broader measurement framework," she says. "We have to be stewards of our own businesses and make sure every investment is grounded in the business outcome we're trying to achieve, not simply the availability of additional media opportunities."

Organic visibility isn't guaranteed, even for a category leader. A brand's leadership in the category or on the physical shelf may not translate to equivalent visibility in digital search. In those cases, paid search can play an important role in maintaining competitive visibility, making it critical to understand both the value of that visibility and the business outcome the investment is intended to deliver. "We can be the number-one supplier with the number-one item and still not have equivalent visibility in digital search. Understanding the business impact of that gap is critical to making the right investment decision," says Farnham.

Setting the right level

Not every number put forward as evidence works as an objective. Digital penetration can be a useful indicator, but it isn't a business objective on its own. The ratio can improve because digital sales grew, or because store sales declined. What matters is whether we're creating incremental growth for the total business. Willette applies a similar test to any number a team proposes as its goal. "A metric can move in the right direction for the wrong reason. Before any number becomes the goal, I'd ask what would have to be true in the business for it to go up, and whether that's something you actually want," he explains.

Any marketing dollar has more than one place it could go, and some destinations come back with a return that's easier to count. Farnham's answer is to keep the retail media case tied to what the investment is supposed to do, and to keep improving the effectiveness of the spend already in place. "Ultimately, the goal isn't to optimize a media metric. It's to make sure the investment is delivering the business outcome we set out to achieve," she concludes.